Ya know, I could rebut most everything you posted, but I'm not going to. This is not the NGT thread, nor is it the assault thread. So if you want to rehash that argument, take it there. Just know, if I were running this poll, using the downvotes to systematically prop up your oshimen would be cause for vote nullification.
Personally, I don't like seeing members described as looking "like a transvestite man." We can do better than that.
Agree. I replied to the wrong post in the wrong thread. But there is a reference to the ranking as far as I mentioned NGT48 members rankings and replied to the Post before. But I don't understand, where the sh*tstorm came from. The crossdresser thing is only a personal opinion. She looks similar to Jonah Blechman for me (don't even ask...) So to all the people: what do you want to hear? What should I do to not being disliked again. I'm personally not the biggest fan of Maho. In my last post I left everything about Maho and her person outside. Is it, that I indirectly defendet Nishigata Marina, Nakai Rika and Yamada Noe in relation to their negative rankings? I guess on that forum you can't even breathe without beeing hated and criticised.
@Dokuro3313 1) Don't make up facts (I know, I know, everyone else does it). Not the right place to get into detail, but Tano didn't make an "indecent joke", Katomina wasn't "criticising the assault", etc. Your defense was at least as misinformed as the usual criticisms of them. 2) Lay off insulting members regardless of your personal opinion. Or at least don't cry about the dislikes if you do. If you're gonna hate, expect to get hated back. 3) In the past criticising others' rankings has generally been avoided (though I don't think it was ever outright banned), because it discourages people from sharing theirs and derails the thread (just like this post ) 4) The alternative you suggested was terrible. Honestly I'm not even sure why this ranking has negative votes, but whatever.
11. (+4) 255. (296) [2|0] [AKB] Mitomo Mashiro{+9,0}, 9 - Mashiro senpai has the best smile (sorry Gyoten), and that's enough to be my 11th. 12. (+3) 279. (---) [3|0] [AKB] Hasegawa Momoka{+7,0}, 7 - I started to like her because of her hairstyle and she likes things my previous oshimen liked 13. (+3) 290. (---) [2|0] [NMB] Okamoto Rena{+6,0}, 6 - 13th.. lol. Since I copied nvmea again, I'll just say the same thing: her fashion style is (mostly) very cool, follow her Instagram
but can she do this?! Saki liked dissing people? Or is previous oshimen actually Yokoyama, I already lost track I didn't put any of the new eitos in but atm I'd guess she's the most likely to be in next year not even putting her in 12th or 14th to make it less obvious btw so you also dropped Honoka?
that's a Gyoten-special kinda: (why do I remember stuff like this) but I didn't mean any personality-related things but I only had 2. And now I'm at my 3rd, but I was kinda forced into it by you and Aka it's nothing against her, I lost interest in STU after Saki graduated
13. Yamada Kyoka (+3) ... 19. Miyake Yuria (+1) 308. (296) [3|0] [AKB] Yamada Kyoka {+5,0}, 5 Last year wasn't neither a wonderful nor a bad year for her, she had a chance to appear in some Team 8's local events, performed on Team 8's stage and got a decent result in SR event which she decided to participate, but her memorable moments for me would be some unit songs she did: Tenshi no Shippo (with Yuiyui and Mashiro) during Team 8's 5th Anniversary performance, Candy (with Yuuna and Harupyon) during Team 8's 5th Anniversary Concert, She did well and looked adorable in both ... therefore that was the reason I voted for her.
I met kudo haruka just last week watching the HKT48 presentations broadcast on youtube. If I could have voted I would give her many votes. That girl is special. I think she would become one of the most popular members of all 48G
It's okay to discuss each others' votes and reasons but it seems obvious that we need to establish a couple of rules. In no particular order: 1. Comment on the vote, not the voter. No name calling. 2. Criticising members is fine. No name calling idols as per usual forum etiquette rules. That includes girls that may have committed crimes. I'm gonna make a spot ruling here that "transvestite" isn't okay. If you must make a comment like that, at the very least change it to "cross-dresser", and you also have to expect that you're gonna get a backlash for it because it's still a mean thing to say. 3. "Disliking" bad behaviour is fine. Disliking votes is not okay and I'll be deleting any dislikes I see on comments that only contain vote results. 4. To an extent, it's okay to have a little back-and-forth regarding your votes. But don't take it to a level where it should belong on a member or general thread. In particular, it's okay to state your stance on the Yamaguchi Maho incident as it relates to your votes but if you want to challenge people's opinions on it, that should be done in the NGT Assault Case thread. I'll keep updating as I feel necessary. If you want to discuss them, PM me. I don't want to distract from the results discussion. New results will be up in an hour or so.
Agree with the above Forgive the rugby reference, but the great words of Nigel Owens.. (skip to 1:30) if the video does not show watch the video here
Day 4 is up! Newly completed teams will be up in the third post in another short while. Edit: teams have been updated. Now most international groups are out of the competition! ============================= I'm finally seeing some of my lower ranks fall in as each yeah I have less and less idol time and I become more lame and mainstream. Spoiler: my revealed ranks 222. (196) [4|0] [N46] Mukai Hazuki {+12,0}, 12 12. +3 222. (216) [4|0] [N46] Nakamura Reno {+12,0}, 12 15. +2 208. (419) [5|0] [K46] Harada Aoi {+14,0}, 14 18. +1
Finally someone else from my list shows up! Except that's not really a reason for celebration yet is it... 18. (+1) 240. (209) [4|0] [AKB] Ichikawa Manami {+10,0}, 10 Fell a few spots this year, which is odd because I enjoyed her activities more over the past year than the year before, enough to earn her a return to my ranking. Not that she did a whole lot, I guess. Still wish she'd hang out more with Megu or other members. Spoiler: Rankings Revealed 01. 02. 03. 04. 05. 06. 07. 460. (503) [6|13] [NGT] Ogino Yuka {+18,-35}, -17 08. 09. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 240. (209) [4|0] [AKB] Ichikawa Manami {+10,0}, 10 19. 20. 417. (384) [1|0] [NGT] Kawagoe Saya {+1,0}, 1
Spoiler: Votes, so far Only one reveal this turn. I was expecting two other to show today (and Hazuki to get higher...) Win some, lose some kind of day it seems.
Spoiler: Rankings and stuff 09. Michieda Saki (+4) 10. Sato Minami (+4) 18. Kudo Haruka (+1) 19. Shiotsuki Keito (+1) 20. Otani Yuki (+1) Only one from me. Satomina another great Team A girl. She was super cute in pd48 and seems to have a good relationship with the other members. Glad to see I'm not the only one who likes her. Glad to see Ran and Orin on there, I considered voting for them after seeing their theater performances. Mukai was on my list but I decided last minute to vote for someone else, I really liked her on the variety shows tho.
BOOM! 01. --- 02. 240. (283) [1|0] [AKB] KOBAYASHI RAN{+10,0}, 10 03. --- 04. 240. (271) [2|0] [SKE] MATSUMURA KAORI{+10,0}, 10 05. --- 06. 189. (149) [4|0] [SKE] TANI MARIKA{+16,0}, 16 07. --- 08. --- 09. 330. (196) [1|0] [HKT] FUCHIGAMI MAI{+4,0}, 4 10. 189. (305) [3|0] [AKB] ISHIWATA SENA{+16,0}, 16 11. 330. (322) [1|0] [HKT] SAKAGUCHI RIKO{+4,0}, 4 12. 279. (170) [2|0] [SKE] HIDAKA YUZUKI{+7,0}, 7 13. 214. (322) [4|0] [AKB] HONDA SORA{+13,0}, 13 14. 230. (129) [3|0] [SKE] YAMAUCHI SUZURAN{+11,0}, 11 15. --- 16. 392. (444) [2|1] [SKE] SATO KAHO{+3,-1}, 2 17. 196. (209) [4|0] [AKB] OTAKE HITOMI{+15,0}, 15 18. 180. (170) [5|0] [AKB] MUTO ORIN{+17,0}, 17 19. --- 20.290. (242) [3|0] [BNK] WARATTAYA DEESOMLERT{+6,0}, 6 01. 463. (508) [0|19] [NGT] TANO AYAKA{+0,-78}, -78 <---My only negative vote And there goes the majority of my list. I know a few members I voted for will rank fairly high, but I would be surprised if more than 3-4 break the top 100. Oh, and please take a closer look at Ranchan, she is a star in the making on Team K
02. 240. (---) [1|0] [BNK] Nuttakul Pimtongchaikul{+10,0}, 10 Last year, I actually was going to vote for her. But for some reasons, I forgot to put her on my list . Glad to see her rank this year, even though I'm the only one voted for her. I'm glad that she ranked well in the preliminary results in SSK, and able to be senbatsu of 2 singles in a row. 04. 196. (262) [4|0] [HKT] Matsumoto Hinata{+15,0}, 15 Another year passed, her rank continue to go up. I remember in 2017 Ranking, I was the only one voted for her. Last year, she had two people (included me) voted for her and her rank went up. 2019 is actually a great year for her though. First HKT48 Senbatsu, and one of the girls chosen for Monica, Yoake da 09. 240. (---) [3|0] [SKE] Hirata Shiina{+10,0}, 10 Just saw her SNS photo and she become my oshi in SKE48 . First IZONE member to be called up in this ranking. Spoiler: Ranking reveals 01. 02. 240. (---) [1|0] [BNK] Nuttakul Pimtongchaikul{+10,0}, 10 03. 04. 196. (262) [4|0] [HKT] Matsumoto Hinata{+15,0}, 15 05. 06. 07. 308. (444) [1|0] [MNL] Ruther Marie Lingat{+5,0}, 5 08. 09. 240. (---) [3|0] [SKE] Hirata Shiina{+10,0}, 10 10. 11. 12. 279. (---) [2|0] [SH] Hu XinYin{+7,0}, 7 13. 14. 290. (---) [3|0] [SH] Zhu Ling{+6,0}, 6 15. 392. (470) [1|0] [TP] Chiu Pin-han{+2,0}, 2 16. 17. 18. 19. 290. (283) [3|0] [SH] Liu Nian{+6,0}, 6 20.