1. Check the 2023 Stage48 Member Ranking Results, how did your Oshimen rank this year?

Battle of the week (NIII vs. G)

Discussion in 'General NGT48 Discussion' started by antares, Apr 26, 2018.

  1. ogiyukaa

    ogiyukaa Kenkyuusei

    Joined:
    Oct 28, 2017
    Location:
    USA
    Oh my god this was tough, the pairings were so on point I don't want to do this again (I probably will) lol

    NIII (8) vs. G (3)
    1. Ogino Yuka vs. Homma Hinata
    2. Kato Minami vs. Nakai Rika
    3. Nishigata Marina vs. Yamaguchi Maho
    4. Takakura Moeka vs. Oguma Tsugumi
    5. Yamada Noe vs. Sugahara Riko
    6. Nishimura Nanako vs. Murakumo Fuka
    7. Sato Anju vs. Kusakabe Aina
    8. Seiji Reina vs. Nakamura Ayuka
    9. Tano Ayaka vs. Hasegawa Rena
    10. Miyajima Aya vs. Nara Miharu
    11. Takahashi Mau vs. Kado Yuria
     
  2. Atabou

    Atabou Kenkyuusei

    Joined:
    Mar 10, 2018
    Location:
    Ohio
    Oshimen:
    Hori Shion
    Twitter:
    HolyShion
    NIII (5) vs. G (6)
    1. Ogino Yuka vs. Homma Hinata
    2. Kato Minami vs. Nakai Rika
    3. Nishigata Marina vs. Yamaguchi Maho
    4. Takakura Moeka vs. Oguma Tsugumi
    5. Yamada Noe vs. Sugahara Riko
    6. Nishimura Nanako vs. Murakumo Fuka
    7. Sato Anju vs. Kusakabe Aina
    8. Seiji Reina vs. Nakamura Ayuka
    9. Tano Ayaka vs. Hasegawa Rena
    10. Miyajima Aya vs. Nara Miharu
    11. Takahashi Mau vs. Kado Yuria
     
  3. Dee

    Dee Kenkyuusei

    Joined:
    Sep 18, 2015
    Location:
    The Upside Down
    Team G all the way!

    G(9)>NIII(2)
     
  4. ForrestFuller

    ForrestFuller Senbatsu

    Joined:
    Dec 4, 2013
    Location:
    Columbus, Ohio
    You know you have to put the winners right? (Giving that you picked two Team NIII Members).
     
  5. antares

    antares Kenkyuusei

    Joined:
    Jun 2, 2017
    Location:
    On Max Toki 315 from Akihabara to Niigata
    Oshimen:
    sugaharariko
    Lol, it is too much :cold: I do not know Japanese. Also each team has 11 members :blink: I will give the prize in some games with special formats ;)

    The results will be announced on Sunday (maybe morning). Then we will have the battle of week 2 and a new game format proposal :)
     
  6. nakotteiijan

    nakotteiijan Upcoming Girls

    Joined:
    Aug 7, 2015
    Oshimen:
    矢吹奈子
    1. Ogino Yuka vs. Homma Hinata
    2. Kato Minami vs. Nakai Rika
    3. Nishigata Marina vs. Yamaguchi Maho
    4. Takakura Moeka vs. Oguma Tsugumi
    5. Yamada Noe vs. Sugahara Riko
    6. Nishimura Nanako vs. Murakumo Fuka
    7. Sato Anju vs. Kusakabe Aina
    8. Seiji Reina vs. Nakamura Ayuka
    9. Tano Ayaka vs. Hasegawa Rena
    10. Miyajima Aya vs. Nara Miharu
    11. Takahashi Mau vs. Kado Yuria
     
  7. Chiarara

    Chiarara Kenkyuusei

    Joined:
    Jan 4, 2017
    1. Ogino Yuka vs. Homma Hinata
    2. Kato Minami vs. Nakai Rika
    3. Nishigata Marina vs. Yamaguchi Maho
    4. Takakura Moeka vs. Oguma Tsugumi
    5. Yamada Noe vs. Sugahara Riko
    6. Nishimura Nanako vs. Murakumo Fuka
    7. Sato Anju vs. Kusakabe Aina
    8. Seiji Reina vs. Nakamura Ayuka
    9. Tano Ayaka vs. Hasegawa Rena
    10. Miyajima Aya vs. Nara Miharu
    11. Takahashi Mau vs. Kado Yuria
     
  8. Dee

    Dee Kenkyuusei

    Joined:
    Sep 18, 2015
    Location:
    The Upside Down
    1. Ogino Yuka vs. Homma Hinata
    2. Kato Minami vs. Nakai Rika
    (Rika has always been my 2nd fav and Katomina my 3rd, but with Katomina's new hair and Rika's recent brain-slip I'm switching their ranks)
    3. Nishigata Marina vs. Yamaguchi Maho
    4. Takakura Moeka vs. Oguma Tsugumi
    5. Yamada Noe vs. Sugahara Riko
    6. Nishimura Nanako vs. Murakumo Fuka
    7. Sato Anju vs. Kusakabe Aina
    8. Seiji Reina vs. Nakamura Ayuka
    9. Tano Ayaka vs. Hasegawa Rena
    10. Miyajima Aya vs. Nara Miharu
    11. Takahashi Mau vs. Kado Yuria
     
  9. antares

    antares Kenkyuusei

    Joined:
    Jun 2, 2017
    Location:
    On Max Toki 315 from Akihabara to Niigata
    Oshimen:
    sugaharariko
    RESULTS OF WEEK 1
    * The winner: NIII (a quite close score: 12-11)
    * Member with the most number of victories: Murakumo Fuka
    Hail Mofu-chan!!! The power of gluttony is proven!!!
    * The most balanced matches:
    1. Ogino Yuka vs. Homma Hinata
    3. Nishigata Marina vs. Yamaguchi Maho
    4. Takakura Moeka vs. Oguma Tsugumi
    5. Yamada Noe vs. Sugahara Riko


    WEEK 2: RANDOM BATTLES 1
    1. Nishimura Nanako - Homma Hinata
    2. Nishigata Marina - Nakai Rika
    3. Takahashi Mau - Yamaguchi Maho
    4. Sato Anju - Oguma Tsugumi
    5. Seiji Reina - Sugahara Riko
    6. Yamada Noe - Murakumo Fuka
    7. Ogino Yuka - Kusakabe Aina
    8. Kato Minami - Nakamura Ayuka
    9. Takakura Moeka - Hasegawa Rena
    10. Tano Ayaka - Nara Miharu
    11. Miyajima Aya - Kado Yuria

    The results will be announced on Thursday (05/03/2018)

    My pick:
    - NIII (5): 2, 7, 9, 10, 11
    - G (6): 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8


    PROPOSAL OF A NEW GAME FORMAT
    Please let me know your opinion on this proposal. If it is OK, I will make the first game this Thursday.
    In this game, we will select one winning member. The game will go through several rounds with random battles. Since some members have more fans than the others, thus having a higher winning chance, I need to apply random eliminations:
    - Round 1: 11 random battles (3 days)
    - Round 2: Among 11 winners, 1 is randomly eliminated. The other 10 members form 5 matches (3 days)
    - Round 3: Among 5 winners, 1 is randomly eliminated. The other 4 members form 2 matches (3 days)
    - Final: In the morning of day 10, the 2 winners of round 3 are announced. In the afternoon, the final winner will be randomly selected.
    The winner will get 2 individual points. Her team will also get 1 team point.

    I think this game is more interesting & more intense. Though, it focuses more on individuals than the teams. Hence, I can use both game formats: 1 Battle Royale (10 days) + 1 Team battle (4 days) for each 2-week.
     
    Last edited: Apr 30, 2018
    • Agree Agree x 1
  10. nakotteiijan

    nakotteiijan Upcoming Girls

    Joined:
    Aug 7, 2015
    Oshimen:
    矢吹奈子
    Don't really care which format you choose. However, I don't think choosing the winner randomly would be a good idea. The random eliminations in the early rounds is OK, but the winner should be the winner.

    My votes:
    1. Nishimura Nanako - Homma Hinata
    2. Nishigata Marina - Nakai Rika
    3. Takahashi Mau - Yamaguchi Maho
    4. Sato Anju - Oguma Tsugumi
    5. Seiji Reina - Sugahara Riko
    6. Yamada Noe - Murakumo Fuka
    7. Ogino Yuka - Kusakabe Aina
    8. Kato Minami - Nakamura Ayuka
    9. Takakura Moeka - Hasegawa Rena
    10. Tano Ayaka - Nara Miharu
    11. Miyajima Aya - Kado Yuria

    NIII: 6 // G: 5
     
    • Useful Useful x 1
  11. mai48_

    mai48_ Member

    Joined:
    Jun 14, 2014
    Twitter:
    maiakikochan
    NIII (5) vs. G (6)
    1. Nishimura Nanako - Homma Hinata
    2. Nishigata Marina - Nakai Rika
    3. Takahashi Mau - Yamaguchi Maho
    4. Sato Anju - Oguma Tsugumi (Anju is the first NGT I really like and I still like her, so the idea of choosing someone over her is a bit (still) off-putting to me, but it seems hypocritical for me to say that when I put Tsugumin & Noepii in a higher ranking in my sig. Anyway, for now, I will choose Tsugumin)
    5. Seiji Reina - Sugahara Riko
    6. Yamada Noe - Murakumo Fuka
    7. Ogino Yuka - Kusakabe Aina
    8. Kato Minami - Nakamura Ayuka
    9. Takakura Moeka - Hasegawa Rena
    10. Tano Ayaka - Nara Miharu
    11. Miyajima Aya - Kado Yuria

    Ah, choosing a winner is a must, right?
    What if I don't really care about each (Neither)? What if I can't choose because I like them equally (both)?
    Is it win or lose, win is everything & lose is nothing? So that's why you will make the matching randomly?
    But if it's for the below format, I don't mind because it has more rounds.

    Rather than random elimination, what about the girl with the least number of being selected. Also, yeah, random winner doesn't sound good. Both won round 3. What about matching them against each other for the final winner?
     
    • Like Like x 1
  12. Floris58

    Floris58 Kenkyuusei

    Joined:
    Jul 6, 2017
    Location:
    Holland
    Oshimen:
    katominami
    Twitter:
    flolfywolfymina
    1. Hinatan
    2. Gatanee
    3. Mahohon
    4. Anju
    5. Reinya
    6. Noepii
    7. Ogiyuka
    8. Minamon <3
    9. Okappa
    10. Ayakani
    11. Yuurin

    NIII = 8
    G = 3

    This one was super easy xD

    Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk
     
  13. May48

    May48 Future Girls

    Joined:
    Feb 17, 2017
    Oshimen:
    Ishida Chiho
    Twitter:
    May2906
    1. Nishimura Nanako - Homma Hinata
    2. Nishigata Marina - Nakai Rika
    3. Takahashi Mau - Yamaguchi Maho
    4. Sato Anju - Oguma Tsugumi
    5. Seiji Reina - Sugahara Riko
    6. Yamada Noe - Murakumo Fuka
    7. Ogino Yuka - Kusakabe Aina
    8. Kato Minami - Nakamura Ayuka
    9. Takakura Moeka - Hasegawa Rena
    10. Tano Ayaka - Nara Miharu
    11. Miyajima Aya - Kado Yuria

    NIII 6 - G 5
     
  14. antares

    antares Kenkyuusei

    Joined:
    Jun 2, 2017
    Location:
    On Max Toki 315 from Akihabara to Niigata
    Oshimen:
    sugaharariko
    You have to choose the winner. It makes the selection harder, so more interesting. Otherwise, someone may say "I only like Ogiyuka. I let her win her match and I do not care about the other 10 matches".
    Without random eliminations, I am afraid that the winners are always among a few top girls. I want to balance voting power & luck.
     
    • Agree Agree x 1
  15. wlerin

    wlerin Next Girls

    Joined:
    Mar 23, 2012
    Oshimen:
    Taniguchi Megu
    1. Nishimura Nanako - Homma Hinata
    2. Nishigata Marina - Nakai Rika
    3. Takahashi Mau - Yamaguchi Maho
    4. Sato Anju - Oguma Tsugumi
    5. Seiji Reina - Sugahara Riko
    6. Yamada Noe - Murakumo Fuka
    7. Ogino Yuka - Kusakabe Aina
    8. Kato Minami - Nakamura Ayuka
    9. Takakura Moeka - Hasegawa Rena
    10. Tano Ayaka - Nara Miharu
    11. Miyajima Aya - Kado Yuria

    NIII: 4
    G: 7

    Ties go to Team G
     
  16. Atabou

    Atabou Kenkyuusei

    Joined:
    Mar 10, 2018
    Location:
    Ohio
    Oshimen:
    Hori Shion
    Twitter:
    HolyShion
    NIII (6) vs. G (5)
    1. Nishimura Nanako - Homma Hinata
    2. Nishigata Marina - Nakai Rika
    3. Takahashi Mau - Yamaguchi Maho
    4. Sato Anju - Oguma Tsugumi
    5. Seiji Reina - Sugahara Riko
    6. Yamada Noe - Murakumo Fuka
    7. Ogino Yuka - Kusakabe Aina
    8. Kato Minami - Nakamura Ayuka
    9. Takakura Moeka - Hasegawa Rena
    10. Tano Ayaka - Nara Miharu
    11. Miyajima Aya - Kado Yuria
     
  17. Enreik

    Enreik Kenkyuusei

    Joined:
    Sep 25, 2015
    Location:
    Minnesota, USA
    Oshimen:
    komiyamaharuka
    NIII(5) vs G(6)
    1. Nishimura Nanako - Homma Hinata
    2. Nishigata Marina - Nakai Rika
    3. Takahashi Mau - Yamaguchi Maho
    4. Sato Anju - Oguma Tsugumi
    5. Seiji Reina - Sugahara Riko
    6. Yamada Noe - Murakumo Fuka
    7. Ogino Yuka - Kusakabe Aina
    8. Kato Minami - Nakamura Ayuka
    9. Takakura Moeka - Hasegawa Rena
    10. Tano Ayaka - Nara Miharu
    11. Miyajima Aya - Kado Yuria
     
  18. ForrestFuller

    ForrestFuller Senbatsu

    Joined:
    Dec 4, 2013
    Location:
    Columbus, Ohio
    My Picks
    1. Nishimura Nanako - Homma Hinata (Winner: Homma Hinata)
    2. Nishigata Marina - Nakai Rika (Winner: Nishigata Marina)
    3. Takahashi Mau - Yamaguchi Maho (Winner: Yamaguchi Maho)
    4. Sato Anju - Oguma Tsugumi (Winner: Oguma Tsugumi)
    5. Seiji Reina - Sugahara Riko (Winner: Sugahara Riko)
    6. Yamada Noe - Murakumo Fuka (Winner: Yamada Noe)
    7. Ogino Yuka - Kusakabe Aina (Winner: Ogino Yuka)
    8. Kato Minami - Nakamura Ayuka (Winner: Kato Minami)
    9. Takakura Moeka - Hasegawa Rena (Winner: Takakura Moeka)
    10. Tano Ayaka - Nara Miharu (Winner: Tano Ayaka)
    11. Miyajima Aya - Kado Yuria (Winner: Miyajima Aya)

    Team NIII: 8
    Team G: 3
     
  19. wetpantsu

    wetpantsu Upcoming Girls

    Joined:
    Oct 16, 2017
    1. Nishimura Nanako - Homma Hinata
    2. Nishigata Marina - Nakai Rika
    3. Takahashi Mau - Yamaguchi Maho
    4. Sato Anju - Oguma Tsugumi
    5. Seiji Reina - Sugahara Riko
    6. Yamada Noe - Murakumo Fuka
    7. Ogino Yuka - Kusakabe Aina
    8. Kato Minami - Nakamura Ayuka
    9. Takakura Moeka - Hasegawa Rena
    10. Tano Ayaka - Nara Miharu
    11. Miyajima Aya - Kado Yuria (IDK BOTH)
     
  20. ogiyukaa

    ogiyukaa Kenkyuusei

    Joined:
    Oct 28, 2017
    Location:
    USA
    NIII (8) vs. G (3)
    1. Nishimura Nanako - Homma Hinata
    2. Nishigata Marina - Nakai Rika
    3. Takahashi Mau - Yamaguchi Maho
    4. Sato Anju - Oguma Tsugumi
    5. Seiji Reina - Sugahara Riko
    6. Yamada Noe - Murakumo Fuka
    7. Ogino Yuka - Kusakabe Aina
    8. Kato Minami - Nakamura Ayuka
    9. Takakura Moeka - Hasegawa Rena
    10. Tano Ayaka - Nara Miharu
    11. Miyajima Aya - Kado Yuria
     

Share This Page