1. Comments where? I'd like to read some (I think). 2. Watching, I found myself really liking her as a person -- of course I don't like classic idol style, I prefer the more relaxed, natural, uncontrolled and non-professional Keyaki style. 3. Couldn't care less if she's a fake Nogi fan, personally. She's trying out to be part of Keyaki, for one thing, and even if she were a fake Keyaki fan it wouldn't much concern me. She's not trying out to be a fan, but to be a performer. I'm reading into this the kind of otaku fury based on minimal evidence that crippled Mon and Habu and Neru's popularity at first, and it bothers me. But I'd better watch her again to see if my judgment was swayed by being excited to see the very first candidate. It happens. In a restaurant, I often end up liking the appetizers more than the main course, and that may have more to do with timing than quality. Thanks for your work on this thread.