Stage48 Feedback & Suggestions VI

So now I don't have the right to reply when I have something to say about what you say? I don't really appreciate the way you talk to me and this is not the first time. I can post for the 10th time, and what about it... I'm literally answering after other people have posted. and thanks I already know that some mods disregard what I say all the time which is why I ask for opinions from other mods. No wonder this forum becomes less and less active, sorry for trying to discuss which is what a forum is made for. Nevermind.

 

I'm one of those who mainly read and rate, but I also post my translations in member threads. To be honest, I can see both sides to this and the question should be "what is common sense?" Many people will interpret that differently, and the 24 hour limit is just a way to eliminate doubt. But then, if subsequent posts aren't related, can it really be considered spamming if it's contributing to the overall discussion or knowledge base?

I have no issue with the current restrictions, but neither am I against what Mana is saying.

Those are my two cents worth.

 

It's also not really true outside of the big threads (that is, in member threads). I find that the rule has discouraged me in the past from posting updates and thus contributed to being less active (as I usually move on to something else and forget that I never posted anything about it here by the time 24 hours has elapsed). So, I'm in favour of a relaxation of the rule, but don't really have any arguments to add beyond what's already been said and my own experience.

 

My honest opinion can be rough. So I'll give considerate one instead.

The easiest way to circumvent 24h rules is having minimum 2 ppl to tango. 1st person to post update that incite the talk. 2nd person to catch the bait and respond, not just rate like in GrabBike. Worthy of note is both person need to have similar interest on thread.

Why I said similar interest is simple. All us forum regular want and can do 1st. But to be 2nd poster within 24hrs of 1st post require more than just sourcelink.
(That's why I have good time reading Nvmea, Sunny, or other response to @Aka post in Eito member thread to the point they are the last person I'll reprimand for spamming. Or why I don't reply to @Mana post on NMB 6-7th gen thread within 24hrs, despite my understanding and interest on their 1-5th gen.)

There was a time in 2018 when my Opera tabs were filled with all 6 48 groups matome site (and more) so I can reply as 2nd or 3rd poster quickly in hours toward, say, HKTfolks usual question on handshake sales in single release thread, Mario and his STU update, Zeroshiki whenever he create a new NMB subthread, Red whenever I got a time to help him less spammy, and especially some rare SKE update brought by sscrla or some other random user as token of "I read and I'm interested in your post".

Unfortunately, I'm not sure anyone followed suit when I'm away.

Tl;dr
Rather than Rule relaxation, get a dance partner. If you are bound within 24hrs, tell your pal to post in your stead IF the news is truly Major. I have hesitation that loosening the 24hr will lead to more, "Sourcelink post" in a day. We already have tweetbot for it.

 

Only in those threads where there's regular daily activity (such as Miichan's )

 

The profiles for Nishi Marina and Hirata Shiina, both from Team E, have now been removed from the SKE48 official website so could their threads please now be moved to the graduated board.

 

Honda Sora is now officially graduated from AKB and her profile is gone from AKB's official page, please move her thread to the graduated section:

http://stage48.net/forum/index.php?threads/honda-sora-sorachan.21200/

Yokono Sumire's thread was moved to the graduation section of NMB, but her title wasn't changed, please change the title to add "Graduated NMB48":

http://stage48.net/forum/index.php?threads/yokono-sumire-suuchan.22310/

Yamamoto Ayaka's thread in the graduated NMB section is also missing something in the title, it doesn't say "NMB48" after "Graduated", please add it:

http://stage48.net/forum/index.php?threads/graduated-yamamoto-ayaka-aayan.15594/

If we take STU as example, for a group that doesn't have teams, the titles for graduates are "Graduated *Group* - Name (Nickname)" in this format.

That's all, thanks!

 

I don't think this is right... This is the same as saying that because a member in AKB was in another team longer, then you'll use the past team in the title. if we do this, then there is no clear format/rule about the titles and it's not organized. I think this was discussed here some pages ago, but what is used in the title is where the member was at the time of graduation. About Mirurun's case she will be a NMB member at graduation, not Team M because it doesn't exist anymore... it's better to keep the same format for every member and group.

Since the rest of my post was ignored, sorry for repeating myself but if any moderator reads this, please edit Aayan and Suuchan's titles, thanks!

 

(I didn't see before that you edited your post.)

48 and 46 have different formats so it doesn't matter how 46 section is. For the 48 sections, it would be good to keep the same format as every other thread, so if the STU section says "Graduated STU48" then the same should be done for NMB who doesn't have teams anymore. About being redundant, well honestly in this case there is no point to write teams either, or groups, or even "Graduated" since the sections already say "Graduated". But as you said, you won't go back to edit all past threads, so let's keep this format then and write "Graduated (team/group) - Name (Nickname)". it's just weird to suddenly stop this format, it doesn't look organized at all. I think all of this was already discussed here a while ago...

 

Mana for mod

 

I don't think this is a good idea. Team M (and N and BII) disbanded months ago now. NGT48 Kato Minami is listed as "NGT48 1st Generation" even though she was listed as "1st Generation" for 2 months (1 month before demotion, 1 month after promotion) and as "Kenkyuusei" for a year and a half. She should still be listed as "NGT48 1st Generation" because that's what she was when she graduated.

Miru is a member of "NMB48", just that. Every NMB48 member that has graduated after January 23rd, 2021, should no longer be listed by their team. If you want to go by the official website for everything, you should include it in this case. It may seem redundant to use "Graduated NMB48 Member" since it's the "Graduated NMB48 Members section," but it would be plain out wrong to class her as "Graduated Team M." I don't think anyone would really care about that redundancy if it's in favour of accuracy.