As I tend to do, I took this "mainstream" thing a little too far. I did a little excel magic and made a ranking of all the voters by how mainstream they are. I didn't use @ethereallimbo's system as I agreed with @wlerin that votes should be weighted. I went with the simplest way of doing that, multiplying each score by final vote total. Example: Giving Okada Nana 1st place would be 15 x 330 = 4950 But giving her 1 point would only be 330 points. This works for negatives without any adjustments. Negative points for members who got negative results = positive mainstream points Negative points for members who got positive results (and vice versa) = negative mainstream points Might not be perfect, but since I'm only looking for rank and not interested in the point totals, I think it works. But I'm not sure if I can show it. Would you guys be worried about privacy? Am I too paranoid about this? If people seem to think it shouldn't be an issue I'll post it. Otherwise just ask for your rank and I'll let you know I got 60/147 so just leaning mainstream.
It's not an issue for me, but I would say, don't share anyone who hasn't shared their votes here already.
No problems on me, but I guess it will be for others. Maybe those who have posted their votes can give their consent first. Sent from my F8331 using Tapatalk
Can you share the results for people who already made their votes public? Or just send me my rank in a PM.
You can share mine so everyone knows how mainstream I am my ranking Spoiler [hide] 01. OKADA NANA (+15) 02. MUKAICHI MION (+10) 03. TAKINO YUMIKO (+9) 04. MURAYAMA YUIRI (+8) 05. ISHIDA CHIHO (+7) 06. IMAMURA MITSUKI (+6) 07. NAKAMURA MAI (+5) 08. OKI YUKA (+5) 09. UTADA HATSUKA (+4) 10. OKABE RIN (+4) 11. YAMAUCHI MIZUKI (+4) 12. TANIGUCHI MEGU (+3) 13. MUTO TOMU (+3) 14. YAMANE SUZUHA (+3) 15. ICHIOKA AYUMI (+2) 16. KURANOO NARUMI (+2) 17. FUKUOKA SEINA (+2) 18. YOKOYAMA YUI (+1) 19. NISHIKAWA REI (+1) 20. ONISHI MOMOKA (+1) I limit my choices to AKB and STU only, otherwise I would be too stressed when making the list. Should've voted for Anju to make it less mainstream..... [/hide]
No problem for me either. Forgot to update my ranking on the Top 10 members though, but here it is. Glad Naachan is 1st again btw 01. Ishida Chiho (+15) 02. Choi Yena (+10) 03. Okada Nana (+9) 04. Yamamoto Sayaka (+8) 05. Hasegawa Rena (+7) 06. Jo Yuri (+6) 07. An Yujin (+5) 08. Kim Chaewon (+5) 09. Iwamoto Renka (+4) 10. Sashihara Rino (+4) 11. Takemoto Yui (+4) 12. Fujiyoshi Karin (+3) 13. Oki Yuka (+3) 14. Ishibashi Ibuki (+3) 15. Shiotsuki Keito (+2) 16. Horinouchi Momoka (+2) 17. Watanabe Miho (+2) 18. Yabushita Fu (+1) 19. Yahagi Moeka (+1) 20. Morohashi Hinata (+1)
If you have already shared your rankings, I don't see how you could object to someone reordering them (say by the final rank, and not your own) or performing some arithmetic to get some sort of score representing what we are not sure. I have no objections to using my numbers for whatever purpose.
I don't mind either. I allready shared my ranking anyway. Spoiler: My ranking 01. Mineghishi Minami (+15) 02. Izuta Rina (+10) 03. Ida Reona (+9) 04. Kashiwagi Yuki (+8) 05. Ma Chia-Ling (+7) 06. Nakanishi Chyiori (+6) 07. Miyazaki Miho (+5) 08. Oya Shizuka (+5) 09. Tanaka Natsumi (+4) 10. Warattaya Deesomlert (+4) 11. Yoshida Akari (+4) 12. Nakano Ikumi (+3) 13. Frieska Anastasia Laksani (+3) 14. Yokoyama Yui (+3) 15. Ego Yuna (+2) 16. Takahata Yuki (+2) 17. Suzuki Kurumi(+2) 18. Shinozaki Ayana (+1) 19. Mogi Shinobu (+1) 20. Sasaki Yukari (+1)
I made the calculation for me and I got 1135. I kinda expected a lower number because it took a while before I started seeing members of my list appear in the ranking LOL
I'm probably being too paranoid anyway. Revealing everyone who posted their ranks or their mainstream score. Or just replied in a way that suggests they don't mind, Spoiler: Mainstream ranking 1. Kiri (14395) 2. O... (14202) 3. MrQazman (13682) 4. T... (13470) 5. S... (13415) 6. E... (13281) 7. ForrestFuller (13176) 8. sakutan (13073) 9. S... (13071) 10. ColorfulMonsters48 (13028) 11. S... (12796) 12. T... (12794) 13. bonjourmarlene (12775) 14. J... (12621) 15. Sailor Miyawaki (12590) 16. steph (12482) 17. C... (12459) 18. R... (12433) 19. Orangerafi (11948) 20. G... (11905) 21. K... (11878) 22. G... (11703) 23. Erbeon (11425) 24. T... (11422) 25. David B (11376) 26. S... (11149) 27. M... (11070) 28. Y... (10999) 29. F... (10971) 30. S... (10892) 31. H... (10794) 32. R... (10765) 33. I... (10763) 34. Rurouni (10759) 35. C... (10686) 36. Yukitie (10360) 37. C... (10336) 38. S... (10321) 39. B... (10276) 40. Generic_User (10269) 41. H... (10113) 42. Arbios (10026) 43. Mana (9979) 44. M... (9939) 45. V... (9821) 46. T... (9816) 47. S... (9815) 48. Y... (9796) 49. Mikuriin (9783) 50. N... (9630) 51. Zerase (9582) 52. Q... (9567) 53. Y... (9376) 54. sakusakukamen (9332) 55. SaitoWinterStar (9284) 56. R... (8982) 57. Heelo (8950) 58. K... (8793) 59. T... (8737) 60. N... (8728) 61. Kanjo (8717) 62. J... (8591) 63. Z... (8442) 64. W... (8273) 65. Tommy Idoc (8260) 66. May48 (8224) 67. ysa73 (8192) 68. theobserver (8135) 69. G... (8115) 70. NyanNyan's Pet (8043) 71. H... (8017) 72. MaiAkikoChan (7971) 73. S... (7941) 74. F... (7921) 75. J... (7836) 76. dutchie (7822) 77. S... (7810) 78. E... (7626) 79. H... (7605) 80. sscrla (7586) 81. D... (7517) 82. L... (7428) 83. wlerin (7411) 84. G... (7328) 85. halcyon (7321) 86. half23 (7319) 87. M... (7316) 88. Crossheart (7308) 89. Lusankya (7189) 90. Seditious85 (7180) 91. convenience93 (7142) 92. T... (7044) 93. D... (6926) 94. M... (6907) 95. D... (6773) 96. T... (6737) 97. P... (6663) 98. Tuhis (6661) 99. JoltFiend (6643) 100. T... (6623) 101. J... (6579) 102. G... (6554) 103. G... (6533) 104. M... (6412) 105. R... (6388) 106. ethereallimbo (6382) 107. E... (6360) 108. K... (6002) 109. S... (5925) 110. T... (5875) 111. M... (5829) 112. nigamushiotoko (5818) 113. N... (5749) 114. C... (5725) 115. Jurinavenclaw (5681) 116. Crystelle (5537) 117. P... (5433) 118. R... (5324) 119. nvmea (5149) 120. F... (5080) 121. S... (4931) 122. H... (4864) 123. Q... (4782) 124. H... (4758) 125. hjr1891 (4650) 126. A... (4626) 127. T... (4367) 128. Tk-Tonkla (4305) 129. M... (4187) 130. F... (4107) 131. I... (3949) 132. G... (3850) 133. R... (3798) 134. F... (3696) 135. U... (3647) 136. G... (3622) 137. L... (3307) 138. M... (3285) 139. U... (3162) 140. N... (3051) 141. L... (2986) 142. Cristafari (2983) 143. S... (2813) 144. M... (2605) 145. T... (2383) 146. S... (2206) 147. C... (2025) 148. EinhanderX (1017)
Fantastic work there! (Lol, I'm close to the median which is 74 With that Berin-crazed oshi @ysa73 next to me )
thought i'll be near the top but anyway and @theobserver what are you talking about, there's no such thing as craze, for @SunnyHighland has set the qualification for that definition too high otherwise at least i would have kicked you out for not voting for rinrin